Alleged Breach of Fiduciary Duties in Retirement Plan Management

Case Details

  • McKendry et al. v. Inspira Medical Centers, Inc. et al.,
  • Case No. 1:26-cv-14001
  • United States District Court for the District of New Jersey
  • Class Action Complaint

Case Background

Current and former participants in the Inspira Health Network 403(b) Savings Plan have filed a proposed class action alleging that the New Jersey health network and its plan fiduciaries breached their duties under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA).

Plaintiffs Donna McKendry, William Connors and Joseph Adelman sued the defendants Inspira Medical Centers Inc., its Board of Trustees and its Administrative Committee.

The plan held more than half a billion dollars in assets and covered thousands of participants. The complaint alleges that the defendants failed their fiduciary duties in “at least five interrelated respects.”

A Costly Stable Value Option

The first claim targets the plan’s main capital preservation option, the Lincoln Financial Group Stable Value Account. The complaint says the account held tens of millions of dollars in Lincoln’s general account. That exposed participants to the credit risk of a single company, while Lincoln kept undisclosed “spread” income between what it earned and the below-market rate it paid participants.

According to the lawsuit, the fund paid about 2% a year while comparable products paid 4% to 6.5%. The plaintiffs estimate the gap cost participants about $8.7 million in lost returns from 2020 to 2023.

Underperforming Active Funds

The second claim is that Inspira kept actively managed funds that charged active-management fees while producing negative risk-adjusted returns and exposing participants to excessive risk. The complaint names three: the American Century Small Cap Value Fund (R6), the MFS Mid Cap Value Fund (R6) and the Western Asset Core Plus Bond Fund (I).

Recordkeeping Fees

The plaintiffs also allege that Inspira failed to monitor and control what it paid Lincoln for recordkeeping and administration. They say the direct fees alone exceeded a reasonable per-participant rate.

The complaint adds that Lincoln earned substantial indirect compensation as well. That included spread income, float income on plan cash and revenue sharing from the plan’s funds. According to the suit, none of it was reported as indirect compensation on the plan’s Forms 5500.

Forfeitures Used to Benefit the Employer

Like many recent ERISA suits, the complaint challenges how the plan used forfeitures. The plaintiffs acknowledge that the plan document allowed Inspira to choose among several uses of forfeited amounts.

They allege that Inspira used those plan assets to cut its own required contributions instead of lowering the fees charged to participants. They also say Inspira made that same choice every year of the class period without investigation, deliberation or independent advice. The complaint stresses that Inspira was financially sound and faced no risk of missing its contributions.

Contributions on Unpaid Wages

The fifth claim stands out among suits of this kind. The complaint cites three separate wage-and-hour cases alleging that Inspira underpaid hourly employees in violation of the Fair Labor Standards Act and New Jersey wage law.

One of those cases, pending in New Jersey Superior Court in Cumberland County, alleges time-clock rounding, automatic meal-break deductions and unpaid work before and after shifts. Plan contributions are calculated as a percentage of pay. The plaintiffs therefore argue that unpaid wages meant unpaid salary deferrals and matching contributions, which left the plan underfunded.

Why Fees Matter

The case reflects how heavily American workers now rely on defined contribution plans such as 403(b)s and 401(k)s. In a traditional pension, the employer bears the investment risk and pays the costs. In these plans, participants bear both the market risk and the fees.

Those costs add up over a career. The U.S. Department of Labor has estimated that a 1% increase in fees over 35 years can reduce a participant’s ending balance by 28%.

The plaintiffs say they are not judging the defendants with hindsight. They allege that the plan’s Forms 5500, fee disclosures, contracts and readily available market data were available at all relevant times, and that the defendants either failed to review that information or ignored it.

The suit seeks to make the plan whole for its losses, restore any profits gained through the alleged breaches and prohibited transactions, and obtain other equitable relief. Inspira officials declined to comment on the ongoing litigation.

Bryson attorneys Jimmy Mintz and Tom Bibby represent the proposed class, together with co-counsel Edelson Lechtzin LLP.

Complaint